{ "schema_version": "1.0.0", "record_state": "release_candidate", "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e", "document_type": "court_order", "issuer": "U.S. District Court, Northern District of Texas, Amarillo Division", "publisher": "Texas Water Sources", "meeting": { "meeting_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e", "district_id": "north_plains_gcd", "district_name": "North Plains Groundwater Conservation District", "district_role": "research subject", "meeting_date": null, "approved_date": null, "date_note": "Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [ { "date": "2024-11-13", "role": "order_filed_date", "qualification": "As printed in original; not a current-status observation.", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 1, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=1", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#source-heading", "object_id": "source-heading", "json_pointer": "/meeting/date_candidates/0" } ] } ], "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf", "source_media_type": "application/pdf", "page_count": 28, "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 1, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=1", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#source-heading", "object_id": "source-heading", "json_pointer": "/meeting" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#source-heading", "json_pointer": "/meeting" }, "meeting_summary": "ECF 67 denies plaintiffs partial-summary-judgment motion and grants the district cross-motion, rejecting takings, procedural/substantive due-process and equal-protection claims. It finds GPU regulation within statutory authority but includes a 14-day, 10-page supplemental-brief procedure before finalizing sua sponte ultra vires relief. Court-described invoices, settlement demand, party acreage claims and modeled drawdown retain distinct roles.", "meeting_summary_evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 1, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=1", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#meeting-summary", "object_id": "meeting-summary", "json_pointer": "/meeting_summary" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 3, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=3", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#meeting-summary", "object_id": "meeting-summary", "json_pointer": "/meeting_summary" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 18, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=18", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#meeting-summary", "object_id": "meeting-summary", "json_pointer": "/meeting_summary" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 22, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=22", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#meeting-summary", "object_id": "meeting-summary", "json_pointer": "/meeting_summary" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 26, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=26", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#meeting-summary", "object_id": "meeting-summary", "json_pointer": "/meeting_summary" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 27, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=27", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#meeting-summary", "object_id": "meeting-summary", "json_pointer": "/meeting_summary" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 28, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=28", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#meeting-summary", "object_id": "meeting-summary", "json_pointer": "/meeting_summary" } ], "entities": [ { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-blf-land", "name": "BLF Land, LLC", "type": "organization", "roles": [ "plaintiff" ], "identity_scope": "source-local; no corporate identity merge", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 1, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=1", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-blf-land", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-blf-land", "json_pointer": "/entities/0" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-blf-land", "json_pointer": "/entities/0", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-blaine", "name": "Blaine Larsen Farms, Inc.", "type": "organization", "roles": [ "plaintiff" ], "identity_scope": "source-local; no corporate identity merge", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 1, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=1", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-blaine", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-blaine", "json_pointer": "/entities/1" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-blaine", "json_pointer": "/entities/1", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-district", "name": "North Plains Groundwater Conservation District", "type": "government", "roles": [ "defendant" ], "identity_scope": "source-local; no corporate identity merge", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 1, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=1", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-district", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-district", "json_pointer": "/entities/2" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-district", "json_pointer": "/entities/2", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-warlick", "name": "Amber Warlick", "type": "person", "roles": [ "plaintiff visualization expert; affidavit excluded" ], "identity_scope": "source-local; no corporate identity merge", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 4, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=4", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-warlick", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-warlick", "json_pointer": "/entities/3" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-warlick", "json_pointer": "/entities/3", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-fearless", "name": "Fearless Eye, Inc.", "type": "organization", "roles": [ "Warlick firm" ], "identity_scope": "source-local; no corporate identity merge", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 4, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=4", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-fearless", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-fearless", "json_pointer": "/entities/4" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-fearless", "json_pointer": "/entities/4", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-thornhill", "name": "Michael Thornhill", "type": "person", "roles": [ "plaintiff hydrogeological expert; affidavit admitted" ], "identity_scope": "source-local; no corporate identity merge", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 4, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=4", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-thornhill", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-thornhill", "json_pointer": "/entities/5" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-thornhill", "json_pointer": "/entities/5", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-oliver", "name": "Wade Oliver", "type": "person", "roles": [ "district hydrological expert" ], "identity_scope": "source-local; no corporate identity merge", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 18, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=18", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-oliver", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-oliver", "json_pointer": "/entities/6" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-oliver", "json_pointer": "/entities/6", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-sprouse", "name": "Sprouse Shrader Smith", "type": "organization", "roles": [ "plaintiffs law firm" ], "identity_scope": "source-local; no corporate identity merge", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 5, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=5", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-sprouse", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-sprouse", "json_pointer": "/entities/7" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-sprouse", "json_pointer": "/entities/7", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-leven", "name": "Sabrine Leven", "type": "person", "roles": [ "GPU consultant; witness as printed" ], "identity_scope": "source-local; no corporate identity merge", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 24, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=24", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-leven", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-leven", "json_pointer": "/entities/8" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-leven", "json_pointer": "/entities/8", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-taylor", "name": "Travis Taylor", "type": "person", "roles": [ "local farmer witness" ], "identity_scope": "source-local; no corporate identity merge", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 24, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=24", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-taylor", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-taylor", "json_pointer": "/entities/9" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-taylor", "json_pointer": "/entities/9", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-judge", "name": "Matthew J. Kacsmaryk", "type": "person", "roles": [ "U.S. District Judge" ], "identity_scope": "source-local; no corporate identity merge", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 28, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=28", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-judge", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-judge", "json_pointer": "/entities/10" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-judge", "json_pointer": "/entities/10", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } } ], "water_objects": [ { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-case", "type": "litigation", "label": "2:23-CV-133-Z", "trial_court": "U.S. District Court, Northern District of Texas, Amarillo Division", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 1, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=1", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-case", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-case", "json_pointer": "/water_objects/0" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-case", "json_pointer": "/water_objects/0", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-aquifer", "type": "aquifer", "label": "Ogallala Aquifer", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 2, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=2", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-aquifer", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-aquifer", "json_pointer": "/water_objects/1" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-aquifer", "json_pointer": "/water_objects/1", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-order-023001", "type": "administrative_order", "label": "NPGCD Board Order No. 023-001", "context": "Court describes January 17, 2023 denial; complete underlying order absent.", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 3, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=3", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-order-023001", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-order-023001", "json_pointer": "/water_objects/2" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 24, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=24", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-order-023001", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-order-023001", "json_pointer": "/water_objects/2" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-order-023001", "json_pointer": "/water_objects/2", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } } ], "episodes": [ { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-history", "topic": "history", "stage": "court_description_of_prior_events", "statement": "Court reports 2020–2022 overproduction, May 19, 2021 notice for 2020, June 24, 2021 variance request, May 2022 notice for 2021, January 17, 2023 Order 023-001 denial, June 2023 notices for 2022, $1,793,461.50 invoices and refused July 27, 2023 $500,000 demand. These are court accounts of record material, not new awards.", "section_dates": [ "2021-05-19", "2021-06-24", "2023-01-17", "2023-07-27" ], "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 2, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=2", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-history", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-history", "json_pointer": "/episodes/0" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 3, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=3", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-history", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-history", "json_pointer": "/episodes/0" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-history", "json_pointer": "/episodes/0", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [], "referenced_dates": [ { "date": "2021-05-19", "role": "attributed_referenced_date", "qualification": "Date described in this item, not a conflicting document date or independent instrument.", "page": 2 }, { "date": "2021-06-24", "role": "attributed_referenced_date", "qualification": "Date described in this item, not a conflicting document date or independent instrument.", "page": 2 }, { "date": "2023-01-17", "role": "attributed_referenced_date", "qualification": "Date described in this item, not a conflicting document date or independent instrument.", "page": 2 }, { "date": "2023-07-27", "role": "attributed_referenced_date", "qualification": "Date described in this item, not a conflicting document date or independent instrument.", "page": 2 } ] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-evidence-rulings", "topic": "evidence rulings", "stage": "court_ruling", "statement": "Warlick affidavit struck for deficient disclosure/authentication of exhibits/data and prejudice. Thornhill affidavit admitted despite late explanation because District adequately responded and suffered no prejudice. Admission is not adoption of his drainage opinion.", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 4, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=4", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-evidence-rulings", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-evidence-rulings", "json_pointer": "/episodes/1" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 5, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=5", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-evidence-rulings", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-evidence-rulings", "json_pointer": "/episodes/1" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 6, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=6", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-evidence-rulings", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-evidence-rulings", "json_pointer": "/episodes/1" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 7, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=7", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-evidence-rulings", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-evidence-rulings", "json_pointer": "/episodes/1" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-evidence-rulings", "json_pointer": "/episodes/1", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "topic": "takings disposition", "stage": "court_ruling", "statement": "Per se and regulatory takings claims fail on the summary-judgment record. Court finds no demonstrated abnormal drainage, insufficient economic impact, no interference with investment-backed expectations, and public harm-prevention purposes. Plaintiffs asserted acreage arithmetic and five-well-area drainage concerns are not approved pumping allocations.", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 8, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=8", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/2" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 9, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=9", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/2" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 10, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=10", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/2" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 11, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=11", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/2" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 12, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=12", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/2" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 13, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=13", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/2" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 14, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=14", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/2" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 15, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=15", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/2" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 16, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=16", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/2" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 17, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=17", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/2" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-takings-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/2", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-model", "topic": "model", "stage": "court_characterization_of_expert_model", "statement": "Court describes Wade Oliver model of additional pumping above 1.5 acre-feet/acre on one historically overproduced GPU: up to 30 feet additional drawdown over DFC timeline 2018–2080, all other conditions static. It treats that evidence as uncontested for the statutory-purpose issue. This is not a measured drawdown or all-GPU prediction.", "date_status": "Years 2018 through 2080 stated; endpoints not exact dates", "model_period": "2018 through 2080", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 18, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=18", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-model", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-model", "json_pointer": "/episodes/3" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-model", "json_pointer": "/episodes/3", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date. Years 2018 through 2080 stated; endpoints not exact dates 2018 through 2080", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "topic": "ultra vires", "stage": "court_reasoning_with_conditional_procedure", "statement": "Court holds Water Code 36.116 authorizes GPU tract definitions and production controls. Although text says it is granting district relief, the court affords plaintiffs a supplemental brief of no more than 10 pages within 14 days after filing; absent response it will grant judgment, and with response it will grant/deny or order reply. Preserve conditional procedure; response/follow-up order not supplied.", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 17, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=17", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "json_pointer": "/episodes/4" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 18, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=18", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "json_pointer": "/episodes/4" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 19, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=19", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "json_pointer": "/episodes/4" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 20, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=20", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "json_pointer": "/episodes/4" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 21, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=21", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "json_pointer": "/episodes/4" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 22, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=22", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "json_pointer": "/episodes/4" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 28, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=28", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "json_pointer": "/episodes/4" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-ultra-vires", "json_pointer": "/episodes/4", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-hearing-history", "topic": "hearing history", "stage": "court_description_of_prior_process", "statement": "Court describes counsel June 29, 2021 verified request, November 29, 2022 notice, December 9 written-comment deadline, December 2 publication and December 13 hearing, including Leven/Thornhill and Travis Taylor testimony; identifies January 17, 2023 order. Page 3 instead describes a June 24 variance request; roles/attributions retained.", "section_dates": [ "2021-06-29", "2022-11-29", "2022-12-09", "2022-12-02", "2022-12-13", "2023-01-17" ], "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 23, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=23", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-hearing-history", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-hearing-history", "json_pointer": "/episodes/5" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 24, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=24", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-hearing-history", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-hearing-history", "json_pointer": "/episodes/5" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 25, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=25", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-hearing-history", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-hearing-history", "json_pointer": "/episodes/5" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-hearing-history", "json_pointer": "/episodes/5", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [], "referenced_dates": [ { "date": "2021-06-29", "role": "attributed_referenced_date", "qualification": "Date described in this item, not a conflicting document date or independent instrument.", "page": 23 }, { "date": "2022-11-29", "role": "attributed_referenced_date", "qualification": "Date described in this item, not a conflicting document date or independent instrument.", "page": 23 }, { "date": "2022-12-09", "role": "attributed_referenced_date", "qualification": "Date described in this item, not a conflicting document date or independent instrument.", "page": 23 }, { "date": "2022-12-02", "role": "attributed_referenced_date", "qualification": "Date described in this item, not a conflicting document date or independent instrument.", "page": 23 }, { "date": "2022-12-13", "role": "attributed_referenced_date", "qualification": "Date described in this item, not a conflicting document date or independent instrument.", "page": 23 }, { "date": "2023-01-17", "role": "attributed_referenced_date", "qualification": "Date described in this item, not a conflicting document date or independent instrument.", "page": 23 } ] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-due-process", "topic": "due process", "stage": "court_ruling", "statement": "District prevails on procedural and substantive due process: court finds meaningful hearing process and rational statutory-purpose basis, and no conscience-shocking infringement.", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 23, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=23", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-due-process", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-due-process", "json_pointer": "/episodes/6" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 24, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=24", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-due-process", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-due-process", "json_pointer": "/episodes/6" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 25, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=25", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-due-process", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-due-process", "json_pointer": "/episodes/6" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 26, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=26", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-due-process", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-due-process", "json_pointer": "/episodes/6" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-due-process", "json_pointer": "/episodes/6", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-equal-protection", "topic": "equal protection", "stage": "court_ruling", "statement": "District granted summary judgment: large landowners not a suspect class as asserted; with Warlick excluded, plaintiffs present no other evidence of differential treatment of similarly situated landowners.", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 26, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=26", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-equal-protection", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-equal-protection", "json_pointer": "/episodes/7" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 27, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=27", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-equal-protection", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-equal-protection", "json_pointer": "/episodes/7" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-equal-protection", "json_pointer": "/episodes/7", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-disposition", "topic": "disposition", "stage": "court_order", "statement": "Plaintiffs ECF 54 denied; District ECF 56 granted; separate conditional ultra vires procedure retained.", "section_date": "2024-11-13", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 1, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=1", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-disposition", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/8" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 28, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=28", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-disposition", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/8" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-disposition", "json_pointer": "/episodes/8", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "supplied_item_context_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } } ], "quantities": [ { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-gpu-max", "subject": "GPU size", "role": "court-described rule maximum", "value": 1600, "unit": "acres", "time_basis": null, "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 2, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=2", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-gpu-max", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-gpu-max", "json_pointer": "/quantities/0" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-gpu-max", "json_pointer": "/quantities/0", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-gpu-diagonal", "subject": "GPU diagonal corners", "role": "court-described rule maximum", "value": 25000, "unit": "feet", "time_basis": null, "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 2, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=2", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-gpu-diagonal", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-gpu-diagonal", "json_pointer": "/quantities/1" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-gpu-diagonal", "json_pointer": "/quantities/1", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-rule", "subject": "GPU production", "role": "court-described allowable annual production", "value": 1.5, "unit": "acre-feet per acre", "time_basis": "annual", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 2, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=2", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-rule", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-rule", "json_pointer": "/quantities/2" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-rule", "json_pointer": "/quantities/2", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-invoices", "subject": "2020–2022 overproduction violations", "role": "court-described invoices total; not award", "value": 1793461.5, "unit": "USD", "time_basis": "2020–2022", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 3, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=3", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-invoices", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-invoices", "json_pointer": "/quantities/3" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-invoices", "json_pointer": "/quantities/3", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-demand", "subject": "Negotiated rule-violation resolution", "role": "court-described refused demand; not award", "value": 500000, "unit": "USD", "time_basis": null, "section_date": "2023-07-27", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 3, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=3", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-demand", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-demand", "json_pointer": "/quantities/4" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-demand", "json_pointer": "/quantities/4", "date_context": { "date": "2023-07-27", "date_role": "supplied_item_context_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-acreage", "subject": "Plaintiffs controlled groundwater rights", "role": "plaintiffs claim quoted by court", "value": 67155.07, "unit": "acres", "time_basis": null, "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 9, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=9", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-acreage", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-acreage", "json_pointer": "/quantities/5" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-acreage", "json_pointer": "/quantities/5", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-claimed-production", "subject": "Plaintiffs aggregate fair share", "role": "plaintiffs calculation rejected as entitlement", "value": 100732.6, "unit": "acre-feet", "time_basis": "per year", "aggregation_warning": "Not a board authorization; cannot override per-GPU limits.", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 9, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=9", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-claimed-production", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-claimed-production", "json_pointer": "/quantities/6" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-claimed-production", "json_pointer": "/quantities/6", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-five-gpus", "subject": "Most productive GPUs", "role": "plaintiffs claim context", "value": 5, "unit": "GPUs", "time_basis": null, "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 11, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=11", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-five-gpus", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-five-gpus", "json_pointer": "/quantities/7" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-five-gpus", "json_pointer": "/quantities/7", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-season", "subject": "Growing season", "role": "plaintiffs claim context", "value": 130, "unit": "days", "time_basis": null, "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 11, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=11", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-season", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-season", "json_pointer": "/quantities/8" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-season", "json_pointer": "/quantities/8", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-pl-value-no", "subject": "Plaintiffs appraisal without rules", "role": "appraisal scenario", "value": 196000000, "unit": "USD", "time_basis": null, "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 14, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=14", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-pl-value-no", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-pl-value-no", "json_pointer": "/quantities/9" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-pl-value-no", "json_pointer": "/quantities/9", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-pl-value-with", "subject": "Plaintiffs appraisal with rules", "role": "appraisal scenario", "value": 180000000, "unit": "USD", "time_basis": null, "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 14, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=14", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-pl-value-with", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-pl-value-with", "json_pointer": "/quantities/10" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-pl-value-with", "json_pointer": "/quantities/10", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-pl-percent", "subject": "Plaintiffs appraisal diminution", "role": "court-stated rounded reduction", "value": 9, "unit": "percent", "time_basis": null, "approximate": true, "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 15, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=15", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-pl-percent", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-pl-percent", "json_pointer": "/quantities/11" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-pl-percent", "json_pointer": "/quantities/11", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-dist-value-no", "subject": "District appraisal without rules", "role": "appraisal scenario", "value": 224180000, "unit": "USD", "time_basis": null, "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 15, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=15", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-dist-value-no", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-dist-value-no", "json_pointer": "/quantities/12" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-dist-value-no", "json_pointer": "/quantities/12", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-dist-value-with", "subject": "District appraisal with rules", "role": "appraisal scenario", "value": 219880000, "unit": "USD", "time_basis": null, "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 15, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=15", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-dist-value-with", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-dist-value-with", "json_pointer": "/quantities/13" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-dist-value-with", "json_pointer": "/quantities/13", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-dist-percent", "subject": "District appraisal diminution", "role": "district approximation", "value": 2, "unit": "percent", "time_basis": null, "approximate": true, "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 15, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=15", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-dist-percent", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-dist-percent", "json_pointer": "/quantities/14" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-dist-percent", "json_pointer": "/quantities/14", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-model-drawdown", "subject": "One historically overproduced GPU", "role": "modeled additional drawdown", "value": 30, "unit": "feet", "time_basis": "2018 through 2080", "comparator": "up to", "model": true, "observed": false, "allocation_scope": "one GPU not identified by number here", "source_text": "with all other conditions static", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 18, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=18", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-model-drawdown", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-model-drawdown", "json_pointer": "/quantities/15" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-model-drawdown", "json_pointer": "/quantities/15", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-brief-pages", "subject": "Ultra vires supplemental brief", "role": "court procedural maximum", "value": 10, "unit": "pages", "time_basis": null, "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 22, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=22", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-brief-pages", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-brief-pages", "json_pointer": "/quantities/16" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-brief-pages", "json_pointer": "/quantities/16", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-brief-days", "subject": "Supplemental response period", "role": "court conditional procedure", "value": 14, "unit": "days", "time_basis": "after this order is filed", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 22, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=22", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-brief-days", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-brief-days", "json_pointer": "/quantities/17" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-brief-days", "json_pointer": "/quantities/17", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } } ], "tables": [ { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-appraisal-comparison", "name": "Court-described competing appraisals", "columns": [ "Attribution", "Without rules USD", "With rules USD", "Reduction percent as stated" ], "rows": [ [ "Plaintiffs appraisal", 196000000, 180000000, 9 ], [ "District appraisal", 224180000, 219880000, 2 ] ], "stage": "appraisal_scenarios", "notes": "Structured transcription of prose, not printed grid; rounded percentages preserved, not recomputed; not awards.", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 14, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=14", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-appraisal-comparison", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-appraisal-comparison", "json_pointer": "/tables/0" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 15, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=15", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-appraisal-comparison", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-appraisal-comparison", "json_pointer": "/tables/0" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-appraisal-comparison", "json_pointer": "/tables/0", "row_navigation": [ { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-appraisal-comparison-row-1", "json_pointer": "/tables/0/rows/0", "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-appraisal-comparison-row-1", "evidence_scope": "table_level", "table_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-appraisal-comparison", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-appraisal-comparison-row-2", "json_pointer": "/tables/0/rows/1", "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-appraisal-comparison-row-2", "evidence_scope": "table_level", "table_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-appraisal-comparison", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } } ], "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } } ], "relationships": [ { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-joint-parties", "subject": "BLF Land, LLC and Blaine Larsen Farms, Inc.", "predicate": "collectively called BLF in opinion", "object": "plaintiffs", "identity_scope": "explicit within this original", "caution": "Collective label does not merge corporate identity.", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 1, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=1", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-joint-parties", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-joint-parties", "json_pointer": "/relationships/0" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-joint-parties", "json_pointer": "/relationships/0", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } } ], "unresolved": [ { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-request-dates", "statement": "Page 3 gives June 24, 2021 variance request; page 23 describes counsel June 29, 2021 request. Preserve separate descriptions, not a silently resolved date.", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 3, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=3", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-request-dates", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-request-dates", "json_pointer": "/unresolved/0" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 23, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=23", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-request-dates", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-request-dates", "json_pointer": "/unresolved/0" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-request-dates", "json_pointer": "/unresolved/0", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } }, { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-court-wording", "statement": "Page 10 introduces the right-to-exclude argument as the District arguing, then attributes it to Plaintiffs/ECF 55. Preserve this wording ambiguity. Ultra vires present-tense grant coexists with future conditional procedure.", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 10, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=10", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-court-wording", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-court-wording", "json_pointer": "/unresolved/1" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 22, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=22", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-court-wording", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-court-wording", "json_pointer": "/unresolved/1" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 28, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=28", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-court-wording", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-court-wording", "json_pointer": "/unresolved/1" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-court-wording", "json_pointer": "/unresolved/1", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } } ], "unavailable_references": [ { "id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "description": "Pleadings, Order 023-001, notices/invoices, ECF 55/58 exhibits, Warlick/Thornhill/Oliver full reports, appraisals and ultra vires supplemental response/follow-up order absent.", "evidence": [ { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 3, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=3", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "json_pointer": "/unavailable_references/0" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 4, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=4", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "json_pointer": "/unavailable_references/0" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 5, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=5", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "json_pointer": "/unavailable_references/0" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 7, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=7", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "json_pointer": "/unavailable_references/0" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 18, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=18", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "json_pointer": "/unavailable_references/0" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 22, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=22", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "json_pointer": "/unavailable_references/0" }, { "source_document_id": "sha256:dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "page": 24, "page_basis": "physical PDF page, one-based", "source_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf#page=24", "evidence_method": "PDF_PAGE_REFERENCE", "claim_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "object_id": "north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "json_pointer": "/unavailable_references/0" } ], "citation_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e#north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e-missing-instruments", "json_pointer": "/unavailable_references/0", "date_context": { "date": "2024-11-13", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "date_candidates": [] } } ], "provenance": { "source_schema": "batch02-source-bounded-1.0", "source_record_state": "source_bounded_extraction", "human_reviewed": null, "original_public_release_authorized": null, "review_scope": "Source-bounded extraction; reading descriptions retained as reported provenance, not independently assigned page methods or human review.", "reported": { "pilot_id": "north-plains-blf-source-chain-01", "sha256": "dc0d2f279c8e498f71eab5fdc35da1fe84441c1b0816fa383c3c4d3b7028255c", "source_bytes": 439528, "source_acquired_at": "2026-09-26T05:33:17.450909+00:00", "source_checked_at": "2026-09-26T05:33:17.450909+00:00", "source_check_basis": "Copied acquisition metadata; no network/source check during this reading.", "extraction_date": "2026-09-26T17:53:28.033339+00:00", "scope": "Complete supplied original; unrelated business retained. Context originals reused separately.", "page_review": [ { "page": 1, "reviewed": true, "content": "Caption, competing motions and conditional ultra vires notice.", "method": "complete page text read; rendered-page visual check" }, { "page": 2, "reviewed": true, "content": "Ogallala, GPU rule parameters and 2020–2022 history.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 3, "reviewed": true, "content": "Notice/variance chronology; invoice sum and refused demand; summary-judgment standard.", "method": "complete page text read; rendered-page visual check" }, { "page": 4, "reviewed": true, "content": "Evidence objections: Warlick and Thornhill; expert disclosure.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 5, "reviewed": true, "content": "Warlick disclosure/report deficiencies.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 6, "reviewed": true, "content": "Warlick excluded; Thornhill testimony discussed.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 7, "reviewed": true, "content": "Thornhill admitted; timing and prejudice; takings claim.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 8, "reviewed": true, "content": "Physical/regulatory taking distinctions and plaintiffs arguments.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 9, "reviewed": true, "content": "Claimed acreage and annual fair share; court rejects arithmetic entitlement.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 10, "reviewed": true, "content": "Access elsewhere; right-to-exclude argument.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 11, "reviewed": true, "content": "No demonstrated abnormal drainage; five GPUs and 130-day claim.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 12, "reviewed": true, "content": "Missing drainage evidence; regulatory taking framework.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 13, "reviewed": true, "content": "Monterey distinguished; Penn Central framework.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 14, "reviewed": true, "content": "Economic-impact authorities and plaintiffs appraisal.", "method": "complete page text read; rendered-page visual check" }, { "page": 15, "reviewed": true, "content": "District appraisal; investment-backed expectations and historical rules.", "method": "complete page text read; rendered-page visual check" }, { "page": 16, "reviewed": true, "content": "Lender appraisal and character/public purposes; footnote rule comparison.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 17, "reviewed": true, "content": "Regulatory taking fails; ultra vires statutory-purpose argument.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 18, "reviewed": true, "content": "Oliver model up to 30 feet over 2018–2080, other conditions static; statutory methods.", "method": "complete page text read; rendered-page visual check" }, { "page": 19, "reviewed": true, "content": "Meaning of tract; Tier 1 and dictionary discussion.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 20, "reviewed": true, "content": "Tract/parcel interpretation; no bar to subdivisions.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 21, "reviewed": true, "content": "District tract-definition authority; dictionaries footnote.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 22, "reviewed": true, "content": "Authority holding and conditional supplemental-brief opportunity.", "method": "complete page text read; rendered-page visual check" }, { "page": 23, "reviewed": true, "content": "Procedural due-process standard; June 29 request and hearing notice.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 24, "reviewed": true, "content": "December hearing witnesses; January 17 order description.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 25, "reviewed": true, "content": "Procedural due process and substantive standard.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 26, "reviewed": true, "content": "Due process judgment; large-landowner equal-protection contention.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 27, "reviewed": true, "content": "No class-of-one evidence after exclusion; district judgment.", "method": "complete native page text read; page rendered successfully" }, { "page": 28, "reviewed": true, "content": "Disposition, conditional ultra vires procedure, signature/date.", "method": "complete page text read; rendered-page visual check" } ], "read_completeness": "all physical pages read; limitations disclosed in unresolved; not a current-status determination", "acquisition_metadata": { "retention": "downloaded_this_acquisition", "original_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf", "request_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf", "final_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf", "acquired_at": "2026-09-26T05:33:17.450909+00:00", "last_source_check_at": "2026-09-26T05:33:17.450909+00:00", "receipt_path": "acquisition/court-opinion-2.json" }, "source_final_url": "https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133/pdf/USCOURTS-txnd-2_23-cv-00133-2.pdf" } }, "source_publisher": "U.S. Government Publishing Office / GovInfo", "record_format": "source_bounded", "canonical_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/groundwater-districts/intelligence/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e", "json_url": "https://texaswatersources.com/data/water-watch/v1/meetings/north-plains-blf-chain01-dc0d2f279c8e.json", "collection_role": "source_linked_research_not_official_registry", "dates": { "source_date": "2024-11-13", "source_date_basis": "Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "routing_date": null, "extraction_date": "2026-09-26T17:53:28.033339+00:00", "last_source_check": "2026-09-26T05:33:17.450909+00:00", "publication_date": null, "document_label": "Court order", "date_role": "order_filed_date", "date_note": "Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.", "source_date_candidates": [] }, "partial_pages": [], "correction_notes": [ "Original extraction unchanged. Archive-relative PDF filename excluded; supported content retained. Page references are not quotations or image-method evidence.", "Source-chain pilot: issuer and source publisher retained separately from the website publisher. Null district meeting dates remain null; dated court orders, map and calendar use explicit document roles. Calendar table evidence lists are flattened one level without changing supporting text; row evidence and grouping retained. Source checks are copied acquisition observations, not this import." ], "content_version": "b25d9ca1bb813f73701c831a5266b72a2b38d25d3a106cec88618d8c0fbee64e" }