Meeting intelligence · Court order
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Texas, Amarillo Division
Research subject: North Plains Groundwater Conservation District. research subject
order filed date
Date context: Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
Source-linked research summary. Verify important details against the official source record.
Source summary
ECF 43 grants the motion to dismiss only as to official-capacity claims against officers, with prejudice as redundant. Timeliness, takings, due-process and declaratory/equal-protection analyses permit other claims to proceed at the pleading stage, not a liability finding.
Source evidence · physical p. 1, physical p. 3, physical p. 4, physical p. 5, physical p. 7, physical p. 8
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
Source and dates
- order filed date
- 2024-03-14
- Document approval date
- Unknown / not stated
- Routing metadata date
- Unknown
- Extraction date
- 2026-09-26T17:53:28.033339+00:00
- Last official source check
- 2026-09-26T05:33:16.607750+00:00
- Source document
- 8 physical PDF pages · north-plains-blf-chain01-566a665ce608
Source date roles and qualifications
2024-03-14 · order filed date — As printed in original; not a current-status observation.
Source evidence · physical p. 1
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
Posting, filing, signature, approval, study and referenced dates retain their own roles. They do not automatically conflict with the meeting date.
PDF page fragments are navigation hints; some viewers may open at the beginning.
Source identity: sha256:566a665ce608db4c444d2b159e1498d3e686a8df23c18c559b37f7a77469d409
Source completeness
all physical pages read; limitations disclosed in unresolved; not a current-status determination
- issuer
- U.S. District Court, Northern District of Texas, Amarillo Division
- source publisher
- U.S. Government Publishing Office / GovInfo
- District role
- research subject
- source acquired at
- 2026-09-26T05:33:16.607750+00:00
- source checked at
- 2026-09-26T05:33:16.607750+00:00
- source check basis
- Copied acquisition metadata; no network/source check during this reading.
Explore Entities and timelines · Dated mentions, without assumed identity merges.
Matters, observations and decisions
Requests, recommendations and approvals retain their recorded labels. A passed motion is a procedural result; conditions are requirements, not proof of fulfillment. Repeated quantities are not added together.
motion
requested relief
Link to this item- topic
- motion
- stage
- requested relief
- statement
- Defendants filed Rule 12(b)(6) motion ECF 20 on October 24, 2023 to dismiss the First Amended Complaint.
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2023-10-24
Source evidence · physical p. 1
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
variance history
court description of prior events
Link to this item- topic
- variance history
- stage
- court description of prior events
- statement
- Court describes Order 023-001 denying variance January 20, 2023 and July 27, 2023 district demand of $500,000 to resolve alleged rule violations. This is not an award or proof of payment.
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
- attributed referenced date
- 2023-01-20 — Date described in this item, not a conflicting document date or independent instrument. (physical p. 1)
- attributed referenced date
- 2023-07-27 — Date described in this item, not a conflicting document date or independent instrument. (physical p. 1)
Source evidence · physical p. 1, physical p. 2, physical p. 3
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
limitations
court ruling
Link to this item- topic
- limitations
- stage
- court ruling
- statement
- Court rejects accrual at land purchase and finds claims timely using the January 20, 2023 final regulatory application decision; equal-protection and derivative declaratory judgment claims may proceed. Cites two-year Section 1983 and ten-year Texas takings limitation periods.
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Source evidence · physical p. 2, physical p. 3, physical p. 4
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
takings
pleading sufficiency ruling
Link to this item- topic
- takings
- stage
- pleading sufficiency ruling
- statement
- At minimum plaintiffs sufficiently alleged a per se takings claim; claims may proceed. Alleged confiscation/offset rights are not proven damages or a final finding of taking.
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Source evidence · physical p. 4, physical p. 5
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
due process
pleading sufficiency ruling
Link to this item- topic
- due process
- stage
- pleading sufficiency ruling
- statement
- Due-process claim may proceed because alleged arbitrary variance denial and missing rational explanation suffice at this stage; allegations of animus are not established fact.
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Source evidence · physical p. 5, physical p. 6, physical p. 7
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
disposition
court order
Link to this item- topic
- disposition
- stage
- court order
- statement
- Motion GRANTED IN PART only as to official-capacity claims against officers; those claims DISMISSED with prejudice as duplicative of claims against the District.
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Source evidence · physical p. 7, physical p. 8
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
Quantities, roles and time bases · 4 values
Quantities, roles and time bases
Requested, recommended, historic, modeled and approved values retain their separate roles. A null time basis does not remove a time dimension already present in the unit.
District-described settlement demand · court-reported demand, not award
Link to this item- subject
- District-described settlement demand
- role
- court-reported demand, not award
- value
- 500,000
- unit
- USD
- time basis
- Unknown / not stated
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2023-07-27
Statement basis: court-reported demand, not award
Source evidence · physical p. 1
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
GPU withdrawal rule described by court · described regulatory limit
Link to this item- subject
- GPU withdrawal rule described by court
- role
- described regulatory limit
- value
- 1.5
- unit
- acre-feet per acre
- time basis
- Unknown / not stated
- time basis note
- Page 1 does not state annual denominator in this quoted description.
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Statement basis: described regulatory limit
Source evidence · physical p. 1
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
Section 1983 limitations · legal standard described
Link to this item- subject
- Section 1983 limitations
- role
- legal standard described
- value
- 2
- unit
- years
- time basis
- Unknown / not stated
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Statement basis: legal standard described
Source evidence · physical p. 2
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
Texas takings limitations · legal standard described
Link to this item- subject
- Texas takings limitations
- role
- legal standard described
- value
- 10
- unit
- years
- time basis
- Unknown / not stated
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Statement basis: legal standard described
Source evidence · physical p. 2
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
Wells, permits and water-domain objects
2:23-CV-133-Z
Link to this item- type
- litigation
- label
- 2:23-CV-133-Z
- trial court
- U.S. District Court, Northern District of Texas, Amarillo Division
- caption
- BLF Land, LLC and Blaine Larsen Farms, Inc. v. Allen Frerich et al.
- stage
- pleading-stage partial dismissal
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Statement basis: pleading-stage partial dismissal
Source evidence · physical p. 1
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
Unresolved questions
Pleading-stage outcome does not adjudicate surviving claims, total liability, collection or later appellate/state disposition.
Source evidence · physical p. 1, physical p. 8
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
Named entities and meeting-local relationships
Names remain as stated in each source. Similar names across meetings are not merged. Candidate relationships remain hypotheses.
BLF Land, LLC
Link to this item- name
- BLF Land, LLC
- type
- organization
- roles 1
- plaintiff
- identity scope
- source-local; no corporate identity merge
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Statement basis: source-local; no corporate identity merge
Source evidence · physical p. 1
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
Blaine Larsen Farms, Inc.
Link to this item- name
- Blaine Larsen Farms, Inc.
- type
- organization
- roles 1
- plaintiff
- identity scope
- source-local; no corporate identity merge
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Statement basis: source-local; no corporate identity merge
Source evidence · physical p. 1
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
North Plains Groundwater Conservation District
Link to this item- name
- North Plains Groundwater Conservation District
- type
- government
- roles 1
- defendant
- identity scope
- source-local; no corporate identity merge
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Statement basis: source-local; no corporate identity merge
Source evidence · physical p. 1
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
Allen Frerich et al.
Link to this item- name
- Allen Frerich et al.
- type
- named party
- roles 1
- caption defendants
- identity scope
- source-local; no corporate identity merge
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Statement basis: source-local; no corporate identity merge
Source evidence · physical p. 1
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
Matthew J. Kacsmaryk
Link to this item- name
- Matthew J. Kacsmaryk
- type
- person
- roles 1
- U.S. District Judge
- identity scope
- source-local; no corporate identity merge
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Statement basis: source-local; no corporate identity merge
Source evidence · physical p. 8
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
BLF Land, LLC and Blaine Larsen Farms, Inc. · jointly named plaintiffs in
Link to this item- subject
- BLF Land, LLC and Blaine Larsen Farms, Inc.
- predicate
- jointly named plaintiffs in
- object
- 2:23-CV-133-Z
- identity scope
- explicit within this original
- caution
- Joint caption does not establish corporate identity.
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Statement basis: explicit within this original
Source evidence · physical p. 1
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
Unavailable referenced material
Unavailable reference
Link to this item- description
- First Amended Complaint ECF 17, motion ECF 20, briefs ECF 21/39/42, Board Order 023-001 and July 27 demand are referenced but not reproduced as complete instruments.
- Date context
- Document/item context only, not proof that referenced events occurred on this date. Source/event dates retain their roles; no signature or acquisition date substituted for approval. Non-meeting documents have no district meeting date.
- Document / item context date
- 2024-03-14
Statement basis: source-linked item
Source evidence · physical p. 1, physical p. 6
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.
PDF page reference · no quotation or image-method claim
Physical PDF page reference supplied with the extraction; no exact quotation or per-page image method is asserted.